Top 5 List: Top 5 Baseball Players

This list challenge of Top 5 Baseball players was given to me by my daughter, and she would not really put parameters around it.  So, I went with my Top 5 Baseball players I would have watched in my lifetime.  So here is the list:  

1.  Greg Maddux

2.  Mark Grace

3.  Dave Winfield

4.  Jack Morris

5.  Anthony Rizzo

It is a tough list to make because as I'm typing I keep thinking Wade Boggs, Ken Griffey Jr., Frank Thomas, Mitch Williams, Brett Saberhagen, Ozzie Smith, Alan Trammel, Ichiro, Charlie Hough, Tim Wakefield, Will Clark, etc.  It really isn't fair, but that's my list!  Greg Maddux is by far my top pitcher and player.  Even though I saw him lose many games, I always knew the Cubs or Braves had a great chance to win when he was on the mound.  He was a pitcher that didn't rely on the heat, but rather he relied on cunning and outsmarting the hitter with amazing movement.  You rarely saw Maddux shaken on the mound and late in his career, I enjoyed watching him in the dugout mentoring young pitchers.  

Mark Grace and Anthony Rizzo have protected first base at Wrigley field the majority of my time as a Cubs Fan.  They both are amazing at defense and while Grace is an overall better hitter, in my opinion, I like their approach at the plate.  Grace was more about the extra-base hit where Rizzo is more about putting the ball in play with an eye to helping the ball exit the park.  

Dave Winfield was just impressive.  Besides being a great guy with a great attitude, he was an amazing athlete.  Coming out of college in Minnesota he was one of six players to ever be drafted by three major professional sports teams (Minnesota Vikings NFL, Atlanta Hawks NBA, San Diego Padres MLB).  I liked Winfield's presence on the field and his home run hitting power.  He was also aided in longevity in the league because of the designated hitter rule.  Winfield lasted a long time and slowly crept up many statistical record lists.  

Jack Morris was an amazing pitcher.  I will never forget the pitching performance he made in game 7 of the World Series for Minnesota.  He pitched a 10 inning complete game to close it out for the Twins.  He was the kind of pitcher who didn't look for the best ERA or pitching stats.  Morris wanted to put his team in a position to win a game.  It didn't ever seem to matter to him whether it was a 1-0 win or a 11-10 win.  He pitched to keep his team in it.  

So, there you have it!  The first Top 5 in my Top 5 series.  What do you think?  Who are your Top 5 Baseball players?  Do you have some other Top 5 topics you would like me to rank?  Leave a comment.  

Baseball Broadcast #1 Sunday, April 28

Minnesota Twins vs. Baltimore Orioles

This last weekend, I had the opportunity to listen to the Minnesota Twins radio broadcast for two parts of a couple games.  The first was Friday night April 26 and the other was Sunday, April 28.  The Twins were playing home at Target field against the Baltimore Orioles.  The Twins swept the three-game weekend series.

This is part one of a summer-long series where I will be sharing my experience and thoughts on different radio broadcasts of Major League teams.  So here are my supposedly interesting thoughts on the Minnesota Twins radio broadcast:

My first impression of the broadcast was that it has a professional delivery with a very soft tone.  There was nothing loud about this broadcast.  Cory Provus, the play-by-play announcer, delivers the description of the game in a conversational style that didn't have what I would consider significant highs or lows.  Any Cubs fan who has spent time listening to broadcasts on WGN radio, might recognize some a bit of this conversational tone from Pat Hughes the Cubs radio broadcaster.  Provus used to do the pre and post game shows for the Chicago Cubs on WGN and he also sat in for Hughes during the middle innings of many games.  While the dynamics of Pat Hughes are quite different from Provus, the description, respect for the game and professionalism on air are very similar.

Where Provus may have picked up his conversation and descriptive style from Hughes, he developed his own soft-spoken delivery.  At one point in the game Friday night, Nelson Cruz, Eddie Rosario and C.J. Cron jacked back-to-back-to-back home runs. This is an exciting and rare show of power from any team in the major league.  Provus gave a slightly elevated but overall level description of the event.  What surprised me even more was that broadcast analyst, Dan Gladden, who I remember to be a pretty energetic player on the field for the Twins from the mid-1980s to the mid-1990s, was as level in his analysis and description of the trio of home runs.  This is not a good or bad judgemental observation by me, because it is the style of the broadcast.  It is the environment they have created, and it works for the broadcast.  My enjoyment of the game was not hindered by any lack of dramatic description of the play.  Even the engineers of the game, choose the soft approach with a quiet crowd mic throughout the game.

That said, Provus does a nice play-by-play delivery with plenty of description for the listener to create the image of the game in his or her head, and Gladden adds good color commentary that compliments the description of the play on the field.

It seems from this weekend of listening, that Provus calls the game for innings 1-4, then Gladden goes solo to describe the events in innings 5 and 6, then Provus rejoins Gladden in inning 7 to do comment, finally, Provus retakes the captain's seat to finish the game with Gladded back on game analysis.  Gladded brings a contrasting play-by-play call to Provus with a short descriptive style of telling the listener just the facts.  While a vast difference from the conversational style of Provus, it is a nice contrast in the middle of the game.  I don't know that I would want an entire game called in the style Gladden uses, but it works for the middle inning as contrast.

This broadcast would be a perfect middle of the summer kind of broadcast where it is a nice Sunday afternoon settling into the hammock by one of the 10,000 Minnesota lakes.  The delivery style of this broadcast encourages that middle of the game nap where you might doze off in the third or fourth inning and wake up in the seventh or eighth inning to catch the end of the game.

Are you a Twins fan or do you listen to the Twins broadcast with Cory Provus and Dan Gladden?  What do you think?  Did I catch the feel of the broadcast or did I commit an error.  Leave a comment, keep it clean and constructive, and let me know.  Stay tuned for my next installment where I will listen to another MLB broadcast and give my supposedly interesting thoughts.